[SOLVED] Show commands without executing them

Issue

I often interactively loop over e.g. my files and want to perform a specific operation on all of them, let's say I'd like to rename all files:

for file in $(ls); do mv "$file" "${file}_new"; done

This works fine. But before invoking this command, I'd like to see what it actually does, so I would add an echo in front

for file in $(ls); do echo mv "$file" "${file}_new"; done

it then shows me all the commands it would invoke. If I'm happy with them, I remove the echo and execute it.

However, when the commands are a bit more subtle maybe including pipes or more than one command, this doesn't work anymore. Of course I could use ' so the special characters don't get interpreted, but then I don't have parameter expansion. I could also escape the special characters, but this would get very tedious.

My question is, what's the best way to do this? I've read in man bash about the option -n, which does "Read commands but do not execute them. This may be used to check a shell script for syntax errors. This is ignored by interactive shells." This is exactly what I need, but I need it for an interactive shell. Note that the options -x or -v do not help, as it will not only show the command, but also invoke it and then it might be too late already.

Solution

This thread would tell you why the option to show commands instead of executing those (a.k.a dry run) would never be implemented for bash.

Refer to the response from Eric Blake:

> My question is why can't such an option or be provided,

A little thought would show why this will never be implemented. What would such an option output for the following:

if complex_command; then
  foo=command1
else
  foo=command2
fi
$foo args

On the line for $foo args, there is no way to know what $foo expands to unless you have previously executed (not just scanned) the complex_command. Therefore, there is no way to dry run what the final results will be without running things, but running things is counter to the goal of a dry run.

That said, you might be interested in the bashdb project, which uses bash hooks to provide a debugger interface where you can single-step through a bash script; it's not the same as telling you what the script would do, but it at least lets you control how much or little of the script is actually run.

Answered By - devnull

Answer Checked By - Robin (WPSolving Admin)